© 2025 WGCU News
PBS and NPR for Southwest Florida
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Fort Myers Beach is rebounding; Taxable values soar post-Ian

“If you've gone up and down any of our streets, there's really not a street that doesn't either have a house that's been completed or a house that's under construction. So we're really starting to see a lot of our residents get the things that they need to get worked out, worked out and start getting their houses built again,” Dan Allers, mayor Fort Myers Beach, said about the town's rebuilding and a hefty jump in property values nearly two years after Hurricane Ian.
Michael Braun
/
WGCU
“If you've gone up and down any of our streets, there's really not a street that doesn't either have a house that's been completed or a house that's under construction. So we're really starting to see a lot of our residents get the things that they need to get worked out, worked out and start getting their houses built again,” Dan Allers, mayor Fort Myers Beach, said about the town's rebuilding and a 48 percent increase over the preliminary figures from last year’s tax rolls, nearly two years after Hurricane Ian.

Meander around the roads in Fort Myers Beach and one thing is very clear, it’s on the mend after Hurricane Ian roared ashore toppling homes and businesses.

Every structure on the barrier island was impacted by the storm. But things are starting to look and sound quite differently 22 months later.

Margaritaville at the foot of the Matanzas Pass Bridge has opened and there are other big-time projects in the not-so-distant future now that the old Red Coconut RV and the Outrigger properties have been sold. These transactions will represent a big infusion of cash to help fuel the local government.

Lee County Property Appraiser

According to a report from the Lee County Property Appraiser’s Office, the value of land and property on Fort Myers Beach is estimated to be $5.3 billion. That’s a 48 percent increase over the preliminary figures from last year’s tax rolls.

That growth is unmatched compared to other municipalities in Lee County. County-wide there was a 6 percent increase.

“Big changes there on the beach,” said Lee County’s Property Appraiser Matt Caldwell. “...Go up and down the beach, more than a dozen major properties that have changed hands. You've got new prices, you got new sales.”

Even properties that haven’t changed hands are helping to fuel the much needed growth in the Fort Myers Beach tax base.

After Hurricane Ian, the value of homes toppled. Those deemed a total loss or swept out to sea were assessed as little as $10, though property owners did have to pay taxes on land.

While that was a win for property owners doing battle with insurance companies and trying to build back, it significantly impacted the town’s ability to keep running with less tax revenue.

At this time last year, the taxable values of homes and properties on Fort Myers Beach dropped a staggering 42 percent. To keep operating, cuts were made and the state stepped in and gave Fort Myers Beach a $11.9 million bridge loan.

“If you've gone up and down any of our streets, there's really not a street that doesn't either have a house that's been completed or a house that's under construction. So we're really starting to see a lot of our residents get the things that they need to get worked out, worked out and start getting their houses built again,” Dan Allers, mayor Fort Myers Beach, said.

This rebuilding of the beach will continue for years to come and that means the tax base will continue grow. As it stands now, the taxable value properties is still about $2.5 million less than pre-storm.

“So we’re rebounding very well. We hope to be back to where we were at least by next year — pre-storm So all we can do is keep chugging ahead,“ Allers said.

WGCU is your trusted source for news and information in Southwest Florida. We are a nonprofit public service, and your support is more critical than ever. Keep public media strong and donate now. Thank you.

Trusted by over 30,000 local subscribers

Local News, Right Sized for Your Morning

Quick briefs when you are busy, deeper explainers when it matters, delivered early morning and curated by WGCU editors.

  • Environment
  • Local politics
  • Health
  • And more

Free and local. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

More from WGCU
  • Gray Catbirds are in a bird family known as the “Mimidae” – because they mimic other birds, other animals, and even mechanical sounds. Other members of their family in Florida include the Brown Thrasher and the Northern Mockingbird – two excellent mimics that we often see and hear year-round as they feed, sing, and nest in relatively open vegetation. They often mimic the vocalizations of other bird species and it has been suggested that their mimicry may send the message that the area is crowded – and cause other birds to search for food elsewhere.
  • Residents and visitors once again may enjoy convenient, stress-free travel to some of Lee County’s most popular destinations as LeeTran resumes free seasonal trolley and tram services. Connectivity and timing improvements made to other LeeTran routes.
  •  As the nation prepares to commemorate America’s 250th anniversary, the Florida Department of Environmental Protection invites Floridians to reflect on the people and places that shaped the nation’s story and the service members who have safeguarded it. On Veterans Day, Tuesday, Nov. 11, Florida State Parks will offer free admission for all visitors to recognize and thank those who have served in the U.S. Armed Forces.