© 2026 WGCU News
News for all of Southwest Florida
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

For the Defense: Justices Respond to Critics

Three sitting state Supreme Court justices are defending themselves in the face of a campaign to get them off the bench through a November vote. Justices Fred Lewis, Barbara Pariente and Peggy Quince face a merit retention vote in November. That’s when voters get the chance to vote up or down on whether the state’s justices can stay on the court.

On Friday, all three justices appeared at a forum and defended themselves.

The Republican Party of Florida and the wealthy Koch brothers are funding the effort to oust the justices. But Lewis rejected the charge of “judicial activism” opponents have leveled at the trio.

"I think that's demeaning, and I think what it's attempting to do is to raise passions and prejudice, and people who are opposing retention will get the same fairness – next week, next month – than if they hadn't opposed. See, there's no vengeance in the law", Lewis said.

If voters remove the justices, Governor Rick Scott will appoint their replacements. All three have been retained twice by voters in the past.

Trusted by over 30,000 local subscribers

Local News, Right Sized for Your Morning

Quick briefs when you are busy, deeper explainers when it matters, delivered early morning and curated by WGCU editors.

  • Environment
  • Local politics
  • Health
  • And more

Free and local. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

More from WGCU
  • Suncoast Searchlight reviewed water-restriction complaints and enforcement records across Sarasota County during Southwest Florida’s most severe drought in nearly a decade and found municipalities are taking sharply different approaches to enforcement. While some jurisdictions actively patrol for violations and issue citations, others rely primarily on education and warnings and provide few clear ways for residents to report violations. We also examine how the drought has heightened public scrutiny over water use, with hundreds of residents filing complaints about sprinklers, lush lawns and suspected overwatering during the regional shortage.
  • Local officials thought a dispute over who would pay to collect a voter-approved school tax had been settled when Sarasota County commissioners agreed in a surprise vote this week to resume covering the millions of dollars withheld by Tax Collector Mike Moran. Turns out, the fight isn’t over. Behind the scenes, county, school and tax officials spent the next few days sparring over whether Tuesday’s commission vote actually restored the decades-old practice — or whether another formal vote would be required before the money could be released to the school district, according to emails obtained by Suncoast Searchlight.
  • A study shows that short movement breaks can offset damage done by sitting and looking at screens all day.